Start with Your Undertone
Before you browse any shade chart, figure out your skin's undertone: cool (pink/red), warm (yellow/golden), or neutral (a mix). This is the single most important factor in online shade matching. You can check by looking at the veins on your wrist: blue or purple suggests cool, green suggests warm, and a mix suggests neutral. Another test: hold a white piece of paper next to your face—if your skin looks pinkish next to it, you're cool; if it looks yellowish, you're warm; if it's hard to tell, you're likely neutral.
Knowing your undertone narrows down the shade options dramatically. For example, the Tarte Face Tape foundation range includes shades labeled with letters like N (neutral), S (sand, warm), and G (golden, warm). If you know you're neutral, you can focus on shades like 35N medium neutral or 29N light-medium neutral, skipping the warm and cool options entirely.
Shade Range Example: Tarte Face Tape Foundation
- tarte travel-size face tape™ foundation: Available shades include 60N mahogany, 59S rich sand, 53G deep golden, 47S tan-deep sand, 42S tan sand, 35N medium neutral, 29N light-medium neutral, 22N light neutral, and 16N fair-light neutral. This gives you a real-world reference for how shade names correspond to depth and undertone. The letter indicates undertone (N=neutral, S=sand/warm, G=golden/warm), and the number indicates depth (lower = lighter, higher = deeper).

tarte travel-size face tape™ foundation
Use an Online Foundation Shade Finder
Many brands offer digital tools to help you match your shade without visiting a store. Here's how to get the most out of them:
- Upload a clear, well-lit photo: Take a photo in natural daylight (not direct sun) with no filters. Make sure your face and neck are visible. Some tools let you upload a selfie and then virtually try on shades.
- Answer questions about your current foundation: If you already wear a foundation, the tool may ask for its brand and shade. This is one of the most accurate ways to translate your match to a new formula.
- Compare multiple shades side by side: Virtual try-on tools often let you see two or more shades on your skin at once. Look for the one that seems to disappear into your skin rather than sitting on top.
Read Shade Descriptions Carefully
Online shade names are more than just numbers and letters. The description often gives clues: 'fair-light neutral' suggests a very light shade with balanced undertones, while 'tan sand' implies a medium-deep shade with warm undertones. If you're between two depths, the undertone letter is usually the deciding factor. For example, if you're medium depth and neutral, 35N medium neutral is a safer bet than 42S tan sand (warm).
Also note that the same shade name can look different across formulas (e.g., matte vs. dewy). If you're switching from a different Tarte foundation, check if the shade name carries over—sometimes it does, sometimes it doesn't.
Consider the Formula's Finish and Coverage
Full-coverage foundations like Tarte Face Tape tend to be more pigmented, so a shade that's slightly off will be more noticeable than with a sheer formula. The good news: the Face Tape foundation is described as providing 'full coverage without the full feel,' meaning it blends well and can be sheered out with a damp sponge if needed. This gives you a little more wiggle room if you're between shades.
If you're unsure, it's often safer to go a shade lighter than darker—you can always warm it up with bronzer or contour, but a too-dark foundation is harder to fix without looking muddy.
Check Return and Exchange Policies
Even with the best online tools, there's a chance the shade won't be perfect in person. Before you purchase, check the store's return or exchange policy for foundation. Many beauty retailers allow returns on opened makeup within a certain window, which takes the pressure off getting it exactly right on the first try.
If you're ordering a travel-size version (like the Tarte travel-size Face Tape foundation), it's a lower-cost way to test the shade before committing to a full-size bottle.

